If you’re in a hurry and just looking for the best broadheads for deer, the G5 Outdoors Montec is the best one.
The onset of the deer hunting season brings smiles on the faces of many dedicated hunters.
Whether you’ve been hunting this popular game with a bow and arrow for many years or just starting out, chances are you’re always looking for the best gear to maintain an edge over whitetail deer targets and rival hunters.
Getting the right broadhead can do wonders for your deer hunting game because they ensure quick kills and the ability to achieve the most ethical shots to prevent undue suffering to wounded animals.
The Best Deer Broadheads Comparison Table
|G5 Outdoors Montec Broadheads||Fixed Blade||Buy Now|
|Rage Bowhunting Xtreme||Mechanical||Buy Now|
|QAD Exodus||Fixed Blade||Buy Now|
|NAP Killzone Broadhead||Mechanical||Buy Now|
|Stinger Buzzcut Broadhead||Fixed Blade||Buy Now|
|Grim Reaper Razorcut SS Whitetail||Mechanical||Buy Now|
|Muzzy Bowhunting Broadheads||Mechanical||Buy Now|
|Swhacker Broadheads||Mechanical||Buy Now|
How to Choose the Best Broadheads for Deer Hunting
All broadheads are not created equal and every archer can attest to that.
In fact, one model may be perfect for hunting a specific species of wild game but totally inadequate for another. That being said, whitetails are some of the most forgiving wild game to hunt.
As long as you manage to get a good hit in a critical area such as the lungs, it’s only a matter of time before they get knocked down and bleed to death.
Even if the wounded deer successfully runs for a couple of yards, it eventually becomes too weak to continue due to significant blood loss.
The good news is that even a 50lb compound bow should be able to hit deer with fatal shots as long as it is not a significantly sized buck.
Please keep in mind that a decent 100-grain broadhead will have no problems hitting big game such as elk and hogs with success so smaller options like whitetail should be no problem at all.
The ideal broadhead for deer should have great penetration. Even though cutting blade diameter is very important in promoting huge blood loss, the ability to pierce through delicate organs such as the lungs is the quickest way to knock down game of any size .
The idea behind broadheads is to create points of contact larger than traditional arrow shafts. As soon as your shots hit any parts of the targeted deer’s body, it is essentially as good as dead.
However, targeting clean shots that slam through the lungs is the most effective way to bring home some deer. The piercing of the lungs can also lead to rapid internal bleeding in addition to the obvious external blood loss.
While this may sound savage, we believe that clean lung shots are the most humane and ethical way of hunting deer due to the quick deaths and lack of prolonged pain associated with it.
Critical Skills for Killing Deer During Bow Hunting
The ability to aim an arrow at an exact spot and confidently hit the designated target across different angles from both short and long ranges is the ultimate bowhunting skill.
Choosing the perfect bow setup with the right broadhead that is able to reach targeted deer, pierce through the lungs, and make an exit on the other side of the body is another enviable skill.
Even if you’re yet to master the art of firing arrows to pass through deer, you should at least be able to hit a portion of the lungs and knock it down in an instant.
Once you have the 2 skills stated above, whichever broadhead you find more comfortable with can be a great asset wherever you go hunting.
How to Choose The Best Broadheads for Deer
There are several considerations critical to the chances of success when shopping for deer broadheads. A few of the most important ones that should determine which specific model you end up investing in are:
Fixed Blade vs Mechanical Broadheads
Firstly, you have to decide which type best meets your personal tastes as well as circumstances such as shooting style.
Fixed blade broadheads feature blades which are revealed and ready to cut. They come fixed with absolutely no moving parts with the potential to malfunction or fail.
The only downside is that tuning to your bow can be a bit complicated when there are variations between its default position and field point position.
On the other hand, mechanical broadheads are designed with completely or partially covered blades by an integrated locking mechanism. This enables the arrow to fly just like a field point while keeping the edges of the blade unencumbered.
Mechanical broadheads have a wide range of positives including more accuracy by default as well as easy tuning and the ability to have larger cutting diameters.
On the other hand, the presence of multiple moving parts means more susceptibility to mechanical failure.
The failure of these broadheads to deploy upon contact with the bodies of target prey is not uncommon. There have also been instances where mechanical broadheads have deployed wrongly due to the pressure from their release or after hitting wrong objects such as weeds.
Whether you choose fixed blade or mechanical broadheads, please be aware of the 2 main types of tips found in either of them.
Chisel-tips provide more bone crushing power which means the ability to slide through the toughest bones.
Cut-on-contact tips, on the other hand, provide enhanced penetration once contact is made with the target deer’s body.
Again, it is up to you to choose which tip type is more preferable.
Weight is an essential factor to consider when searching for the best broadheads for deer.
Keep in mind that the weight of a specific broadhead determines how much kinetic energy is transferred upon contact with targets.
The good news is that the lightest broadheads usually experience no issues penetrating target game such as deer and turkeys.
However, to be on the safe side, I’d recommend choosing a 100-grain model for your deer hunts.
Number of Blades
What is the best number of broadhead blades for hunting deer? Well, it is no secret that there are so many options on the market right now.
However, you don’t necessarily need to purchase a model with too many blades.
In fact, a 2-blade or 3-blade broadhead should be more than adequate to knock down whitetail and similarly sized game whether you opt for a mechanical or fixed blade model.
Sure, there are some 4-blade options out there but the strength of the blade tends to get weaker as their number keeps increasing.
The best cutting diameter for hunting deer is anything that measures over an inch.
If you happen to find something larger that shoots well, it won’t hurt to go for it especially for bowhunters with a preference for mechanical broadheads.
In fact, it is not uncommon for 2-blade mechanical broadheads to feature cutting diameters measuring 2 inches.
The G5 Outdoors Montec is one of the best broadheads for deer. This fixed-blade model has been tried, tested, and proven to be exceptional at hitting all kinds of targets from any angle and in any situation.
It features a specially designed blade angle that supercharges penetration and takes knockdown effect to unimaginable levels. By the time you reach the spot where that deer got hit, it would have bled to death already.
The 100-grain weight option is the best-selling one among fans of this awesome broadhead but you can also choose the 85-grain or 125-grain weights as well.
Each Montec ships with a cutting diameter ranging from 1-1 1/8 inches. Also, it is really easy to use. You just have to screw them on an arrow to start shooting immediately.
The G5 Montec is the safest bet if you’re looking for top broadheads to stand in the way of any size of whitetail deer that tries to escape into the woods.
The Rage Bowhunting Xtreme Series is one of the most outstanding mechanical broadheads for deer at the moment.
Released by a manufacturer with a renowned reputation for accuracy, this model creates legendary wound channels that can kill deer and other types of wild game to devastating effect.
They come in a rear-deploying SlipCam design featuring blades of impressive sizes including 0.35 inches of razor-sharp expandable blades derived from quality stainless steel.
Additionally, the 100-grain packs come with a 2.3-inch cutting diameter that causes severe damage to the bodies of deer. They make large entry and exit wounds that lead to quick deaths immediately upon making contact.
The Xtreme Series promotes enhanced penetration which simplifies the ability to reach the most important organs in target prey such as the lungs.
This becomes possible thanks to this model’s built-in functionality which enables the maintenance of kinetic energy longer than the competition.
The Rage Bowhunting Xtreme Series is definitely the way to go if you’re serious about hunting deer efficiently with mechanical broadheads.
Independent online reviews are some of the most efficient ways to determine whether to buy a particular broadhead or not.
A quick peek on Amazon and other online retail giants eliminate any doubts about this fixed-blade broadhead being anything but special.
The QAD Exodus features a well-engineered head with the ability to burst through the thickest and hardest bone structures to cause lethal damage.
It also comes with sharp blades measuring 0.40 inches thick at technologically advanced angles with 1.25 inches of cutting diameter. This simply means they’re able to create sizable wounds upon contact with the bodies of deer.
Additionally, the Exodus is designed to match the length of field points to ensure levels of accuracy never experienced previously in the fixed-blade broadhead industry.
Ordering the QAD Exodus is a no-brainer if you’re searching for a fixed blade broadhead with revolutionary accuracy for hunting deer, elk, and other types of wild game.
Deer hunters of all skill levels are turning to this mechanical broadhead in their quest to hit target prey ruthlessly.
The NAP Killzone is an industry-leading 100-grain mechanical broadhead with a 2-inch cutting diameter.
It features a mind-blowing trophy tip that enables extreme cutting and penetration of target prey’s body. The infusion of dual blades create more damage to the bodies of target deer immediately the fired arrow makes contact with your designated prey.
These blades and tips provide greater value for money via their ability to survive multiple contacts with ribs, shoulders, and other bones from multiple uses on a consistent basis.
The Killzone is powered by the manufacturer’s Spring Clip technology which eliminates the chances of your blades getting deployed midflight or during storage in a quiver.
Additionally, the absence of O-rings and rubber bands means you have less to worry about in terms of mechanical failures.
The NAP Killzone can be a worthy purchase if you’re looking for top quality mechanical broadheads for deer hunting with superior confidence.
The Stinger Buzzcut has become a favorite among bowhunters with a preference for targeting deer and other similarly-sized wild game.
It is embedded with Chiseled Serration Technology to provide the most lethal cut-throughs of the internal areas of target animals’ bodies.
This usually results in the production of significant blood trails to help you trace the path of wounded animals to its final knockdown location.
This fixed blade broadhead is derived from knife-grade stainless steel to ensure massive cuts every time. It ships laser-sharp right out of the box and ready to hunt.
Thanks to the precision-machined and extensive spin testing of each unit before shipment, you can expect every shot to achieve the perfect flight and optimum penetration upon hitting the target.
The Stinger Buzzcut is recommended for bowhunters looking for the best 4-blade arrow broadheads for hunting deer of any size, from any distance, and at any angle.
The Grim Reaper Razorcut is a world-class mechanical broadhead specially designed for whitetail deer and turkey hunters with higher kinetic energy bows.
It features thick blades measuring 0.35 inches each which make fatal cuts in the bodies of targets with little effort, leading to massive blood losses and quicker deaths.
The 3-blade cuts weigh 100 grains which is the perfect weight for generating sufficient knockdown power for a wild game of any size.
This also leads to massive blood trails that can be easily followed to find wounded targets when hunting from long range.
Looking for broadheads that achieve complete pass-throughs of deer? The Grim Reaper is one of the most adept models at creating a sharp entry and exit wounds.
If you’re seeking the best mechanical broadheads for deer with fatal accuracy, exceptional flight, and superior durability, the Grim Reaper Razorcut is a must-have.
The Muzzy Bowhunting Broadheads come in a 4-blade design that can take your bowhunting experience to all new levels.
The blades are manufactured from vented stainless steel which is noted for making large-sized cuts on impact.
They measure 0.020 inches with a cutting diameter of an inch.
These fixed-blade mechanical broadheads feature a steel refined Trocar tip that provides optimum penetration and maximum flight stability.
The Muzzy achieves exceptional penetration thanks to its hollow-ground design and anodized aluminum ferrule which offers maximum kinetic energy.
It is available in 90-grain and 100-grain weights, each of which is heavy enough to knockdown whitetail deer of any size.
Additionally, they’re proudly made in the United States by an iconic brand known for the quality of its fixed blade broadhead range.
The Muzzy Bowhunting Broadheads are recommended for any hunter looking for fixed 4-blade broadheads to hunt deer with precision.
Few mechanical broadheads come close to the accuracy and flying power of this 2-blade piece.
The Swhacker Set of 3-100 Grain mechanical broadheads can be a worthy purchase for the committed whitetail turkey hunter.
The awesome flight trajectory of this model makes it stand out as one of the go-to broadheads for pinpoint accuracy. It simply flies in the direction you want with maximum speeds to hit targets and cause fatal damage in real-time.
The only downside is that the blades may require a bit of sharpening out of the box for hunters who demand surgically-sharp broadhead blades. However, we have verified that this model gets the job done anyway even without sharpening the blades.
Also, the large 2-inch cutting diameter makes outstanding entry and exit wounds that can force a huge amount of blood to rush out of the target’s body making certain death only a few moments away.
Swhacker Set of 3-100 Grain mechanical broadheads is recommended for both short-range and long-range whitetail deer hunts.
The G5 Montec Outdoors and the Grim Reaper are the best broadheads for deer. If you prefer fixed blade models, the Montec is number one. The Grim Reaper also stands out as the top option for mechanical broadheads.
Both of these models provide extreme precision as well as laser targeted flying power and world-class penetration.
Don’t like any of our top 2 recommended picks? Feel free to choose any of the other reviewed options here that best suits your needs.